Crisis PR Done Right in the Fashion Industry

The fashion industry, known for its high stakes and fast-paced environment, has seen its fair share of PR crises over the years. The nature of fashion—where public perception, brand image, and consumer sentiment are paramount—means that handling a crisis effectively can make or break a brand’s reputation. Here, we delve into several notable examples of fashion industry crises that were managed with skill and strategic acumen, illustrating how these brands navigated troubled waters to emerge resilient.

1. H&M’s 2018 “Coolest Monkey in the Jungle” Controversy

Crisis Summary: In January 2018, H&M faced significant backlash for an ad featuring a Black child wearing a sweatshirt with the slogan “Coolest Monkey in the Jungle.” The image was widely criticized as racially insensitive and led to protests and calls for a boycott.

Crisis Management Approach:

• Immediate Acknowledgment: H&M responded quickly by removing the ad and issuing an apology. The company admitted the mistake and expressed regret over the offense caused.
• Public Apology and Transparency: The CEO of H&M, Karl-Johan Persson, publicly apologized, stating that the company was “deeply sorry” for the incident. H&M committed to reviewing their policies and practices to prevent future issues.
• Action Plan: H&M launched a comprehensive review of their internal processes and practices related to diversity and inclusion. They pledged to increase their focus on diversity within their creative and marketing teams.
• Community Engagement: To address the concerns, H&M held meetings with representatives from various communities to understand their perspectives better and to work on improving their practices.

Outcome: While the incident initially damaged H&M’s reputation, the company’s swift and transparent response helped to mitigate long-term damage. By committing to internal reviews and changes, H&M demonstrated a genuine intent to address the underlying issues and improve their practices.

2. Burberry’s 2019 Hoodie Controversy

Crisis Summary: In February 2019, Burberry faced criticism for a hoodie featuring a noose around the neck. The image was condemned as insensitive and inappropriate, particularly given the historical context of lynching.

Crisis Management Approach:

• Prompt Apology: Burberry’s CEO, Marco Gobbetti, issued an immediate apology, acknowledging the insensitivity of the design and expressing deep regret for the oversight.
• Internal Review: The company conducted an internal review to assess how the design was approved and why it was not flagged earlier. Burberry also publicly committed to ensuring that their design process would be revised to prevent such incidents in the future.
• Community Engagement: Burberry engaged with affected communities and sought their input on how to address the situation. They also donated to anti-bullying and anti-racism charities as a gesture of goodwill.
• Revamping Practices: The company made changes to their design approval process and increased their focus on ethical considerations in their design choices.

Outcome: Burberry’s response, which included a combination of a swift apology, internal review, and community engagement, helped to repair their image. The company’s commitment to revising their practices and supporting relevant charities showed a proactive approach to addressing the crisis.

3. Prada’s 2018 Blackface Figurines

Crisis Summary: In December 2018, Prada faced criticism for window displays featuring figurines that were deemed racially insensitive due to their resemblance to blackface imagery. The figurines were part of a holiday display in New York City.

Crisis Management Approach:

• Immediate Action: Prada swiftly removed the figurines from their displays and issued a public apology. The company acknowledged the insensitivity of the imagery and expressed regret for the offense caused.
• Engagement with Activists: Prada engaged with racial justice organizations to understand the impact of the incident better. They sought input on how to address the concerns and prevent future issues.
• Educational Initiatives: Prada launched educational programs on cultural sensitivity and diversity for their staff. They also committed to increasing diversity within their design and marketing teams.
• Public Communication: Prada communicated their actions and commitments publicly, detailing the steps they were taking to address the crisis and improve their practices.

Outcome: Prada’s response, including immediate action to remove the offending display, engagement with activists, and educational initiatives, helped to restore their reputation. The company’s willingness to engage with the affected communities and take meaningful steps towards improvement was key in managing the crisis effectively.

4. Gucci’s 2019 Blackface Sweater Incident

Crisis Summary: In February 2019, Gucci faced backlash for a sweater that was criticized for resembling blackface. The sweater, which featured a black turtleneck with a cut-out for the mouth and red lips, was condemned for its offensive imagery.

Crisis Management Approach:

• Prompt Apology and Recall: Gucci issued an immediate apology and withdrew the sweater from their stores. The company acknowledged the insensitivity of the design and expressed regret for the harm caused.
• Internal Changes: Gucci conducted an internal review and made significant changes to their diversity and inclusion practices. This included hiring a global chief diversity officer and implementing new guidelines for cultural sensitivity in their design processes.
• Community Outreach: Gucci engaged with various communities and organizations to address the concerns and work on improving their practices. They also made donations to organizations supporting racial justice and diversity.
• Public Commitment: Gucci publicly shared their action plan and commitment to improving their practices, which included increasing diversity within their creative and design teams and implementing educational programs on cultural sensitivity.

Outcome: Gucci’s response was widely regarded as effective in managing the crisis. The company’s swift action to recall the sweater, combined with their commitment to internal and external changes, helped to address the backlash and restore their brand image.

5. Louis Vuitton’s 2021 Artist Collaboration Controversy

Crisis Summary: In 2021, Louis Vuitton faced controversy over a collaboration with an artist whose past work was criticized for its insensitive portrayal of certain cultural themes. The partnership led to backlash from cultural advocates and social media users.

Crisis Management Approach:

• Public Apology: Louis Vuitton issued a public apology, acknowledging the concerns raised about the artist’s past work and expressing regret for the offense caused.
• Termination of Collaboration: The brand ended their collaboration with the artist and removed related products from their stores. This decision was communicated clearly to the public.
• Commitment to Diversity: Louis Vuitton committed to enhancing their diversity and inclusion efforts, including revising their artist selection process and implementing new guidelines to ensure cultural sensitivity.
• Engagement and Dialogue: The company engaged with cultural advocates and organizations to better understand the issues and to seek guidance on how to improve their practices.

Outcome: Louis Vuitton’s approach, which included a public apology, termination of the collaboration, and a commitment to improving diversity and inclusion, helped to manage the crisis effectively. The brand’s willingness to engage in dialogue and make changes demonstrated their commitment to addressing the concerns raised.

6. Balenciaga’s 2022 Advertising Campaign Controversy

Crisis Summary: In November 2022, Balenciaga faced a PR crisis over an advertising campaign that was criticized for its inappropriate imagery involving children. The campaign featured children holding teddy bears dressed in bondage gear, which was widely condemned as disturbing and inappropriate.

Crisis Management Approach:

• Immediate Apology: Balenciaga issued a swift and comprehensive apology, acknowledging the insensitivity of the campaign and expressing regret for the offense caused.
• Campaign Withdrawal: The company promptly removed the campaign from all platforms and discontinued the associated merchandise. They also conducted an internal review of their advertising practices.
• Revised Policies: Balenciaga announced a revision of their internal processes for approving marketing campaigns and implemented stricter guidelines to prevent similar issues in the future.
• Support for Affected Parties: The company worked with child advocacy organizations to address the concerns and offered support to affected parties.

Outcome: Balenciaga’s response, including an immediate apology, withdrawal of the campaign, and revision of their policies, was crucial in managing the crisis. The company’s proactive approach helped to mitigate the damage and restore trust.

Conclusion

The fashion industry’s high-profile nature makes it particularly susceptible to PR crises, but these examples illustrate that effective crisis management can help brands navigate even the most challenging situations. The key to handling a PR crisis effectively involves:

1. Swift Acknowledgment: Promptly recognizing the issue and taking responsibility is crucial in addressing public concerns.
2. Transparent Communication: Clear and honest communication helps to build trust and demonstrate a genuine commitment to resolving the problem.
3. Action and Accountability: Implementing concrete actions to address the issue and prevent future occurrences shows a commitment to improvement.
4. Engagement with Affected Communities: Engaging with the communities affected by the crisis helps to understand their concerns and rebuild relationships.

By adopting these strategies, fashion brands can manage crises effectively and emerge stronger, maintaining their reputation and continuing to resonate with their audience.

Discover PR practice areas that raise brands, sales and bottom-line results.

Cybersecurity PR & Cybersecurity Digital Marketing
Gaming and Video Game PR & Digital Marketing
Travel PR & Hospitality PR
Digital Marketing Agency